Written By Janelle Martel

We know, with so many awesome edible cookie dough flavors, it can be difficult to choose! If you’re not quite sure what to dive into next, we’ve created a guide to picking the perfect cookie dough flavor for your personality.  How does your choice stack up?

Aquarius (January 20-February 18)

As an Aquarius, you’re an interesting blend - you can be quieter, but you also have a more energetic side.  A natural optimism and creative, you need a cookie dough flavor that satisfies your curiosity for a variety of flavors, yet appeals to just about everyone.  You’ll love the combo of Milk ‘N Cookies, which blends crumbly chocolate sandwich cookies with a satisfying vanilla bean frosting in our  classic edible sugar cookie dough.

Pisces (February 19-March 20)

With a gentle, friendly, and comforting personality, Pisces need something classic and cozy like our Chocolate Chip Off the Ol’ Block (V & GF) which has decadent Belgium dark chocolate chips and the perfect touch of vanilla and brown sugar.  Because you’re intuitive and thoughtful, we’ve opted for our vegan and gluten-free version of this classic flavor, so it’s free of butter and flour.

Aries (March 20-April 19)

A little bit classic and a little bit fiery and passionate, Aries crave an indulgent flavor that matches their intensity.  For this, we’ve chosen our Peanut Butta Cup flavor, which combines two flavors that are satisfying on their own to create an incredible mix:  a rich chocolate cookie dough swirled with an all-natural chunky peanut butter cookie dough.

Taurus (April 19-May 20)

As someone who is always reliable, practical, sweet, and patient, you need an edible cookie dough flavor that allows you to indulge and revel in a little luxury.  Satisfy your sweet tooth with our Brownie Batter flavor, which is super chocolatey thanks to Belgium cocoa powder but still has a delicious dash of vanilla.

Gemini (May 21-June 21)

Geminis are super adaptable and ever-changing.  As someone who loves family and being social, you need something comforting that offers you the best of both worlds.  For you, we’ve chosen Milk N’ Cookies, a sweet treat that lets you enjoy the perfect balance of chocolate and vanilla.

Cancer (June 21-July 22)

Ah, Cancer,  a loyal, nurturing, and emotional sign that deserves to sink into a dessert that comforts this soft side.  Grab our Snicker-Dude flavor which has that comforting chewy sugar cookie dough texture topped with a nostalgic dusting of cinnamon and sugar.

Leo (July 23-August 22)

As someone who is always cheerful, fun, and generous, you need a unique and creative flavor.  Opt for S’more Please, which allows you to enjoy this fun campfire treat in edible cookie dough form. Think marshmallow cookie dough with plenty of mini marshmallows, Belgium chocolate chips, and graham cracker crumbs.

Virgo (August 23-September 22)

As someone practical, refined, and kind, you’ll love our Original Dough Schmo.  Free of any mix-ins, it allows the mellow flavors of pure vanilla and fresh nutmeg to shine through.  Plus, as one of the most health-conscious signs, you’ll appreciate that all the ingredients are natural and non-GMO.

Libra (September 23-October 22)

For someone who is blissful, social, and cheerful, let Vegan Birthday Bash boost your mood. Our vegan edible sugar cookie dough is mixed with vanilla frosting and yummy confetti rainbow sprinkles.  Plus, thoughtful Libras will love that it’s made with Earth Balance or coconut oil instead of butter to keep it vegan-friendly.

Scorpio (October 23-November 21)

Scorpios are passionate, fiery, and charming, and love a rich, decadent edible cookie dough with fun contrasting textures.  For you, we present our Cookies N’ Dream, which has a rich, chocolatey cookie dough base and is packed with chocolate sandwich cookies filled with satisfying vanilla frosting for an indulgent-feeling treat.

Sagittarius (November 22-December 21)

As someone who is playful, optimistic, and ambitious, you enjoy trying new, interesting foods.  Our Maple Fudge Waffle edible cookie dough flavor is the perfect fusion between breakfast and dessert and has a comforting maple cookie dough base swirled with satisfying fudge and perfectly crisp pancake and waffle pieces. Sorry folks, we sold out of that one fast!

Capricorn (December 21-January 21)

As a Type-A, grounded, and family-orientated sign, you crave something traditional.  Stick with our Plain Jane flavor, which will remind you of the classic sugar cookies you enjoy with your family during the holidays, with cozy vanilla and fresh nutmeg.